{"app_id":"fyv2a0qw"}

Head-to-head

Poll complete
50 people answered in 29 minutes.
50 US-based respondentsJune 10, 2021Public
June 10, 2021Public

Q: Based on the description, which book would you rather buy?

Head-to-head poll

Not statistically significant
Tied PickFu winner
On the surface, Caroline Elizabeth Rose Thornton (“Sessy”) is a Southern belle from Tallulah Falls, Georgia--dainty, demure, and genteel. Behind it all, though, she is a tenacious business tycoon. At the moment, angry and ready to reclaim her stakes in a wayward company in the West Indies. There’s just one problem--Sessy is eighty-nine years old and in no position to make the long trip, much less carry on any sort of investigation. Her only hope is her great niece, Pepper May Thornton. An unexpected telephone call from her Aunt Sessy one quiet, Sunday afternoon complicates Pepper’s already stressful life as a bank manager in New York City. St. Kitts, West Indies would never have made it on her list of places to visit, let alone carry out a dangerous mission as time is running out. Pepper’s trip to St. Kitts turns out to be more than just a corporate investigation. On her way to completing her assignment, she must make some tough decisions and intermingle with local people, the intrepid Damian Finch being one of them. Will her conscience allow her to do whatever is needed to stop the ruthless company? Will life on the tiny tropical island teach Pepper the true meaning of loyalty, courage, and tolerance?
A
25 votes

50%
Tied PickFu winner
On a quiet, Sunday afternoon, an unexpected telephone call from her Aunt Sessy changes everything for Pepper May Thornton, a young bank manager in New York City. One moment Pepper is at Sessy’s mansion in Tallulah Falls, Georgia reviewing old business records; the next, before she could think twice, on a plane heading to the Caribbean to investigate BNL, Ltd., a wayward company on the tiny island of St. Kitts. Pepper and Sessy know that the company is full of corruption, but they can’t prove itㅡat least not without Pepper secretly infiltrating as a company employee and going undercover to expose the truth! Determined to fulfill Sessy’s wishes, brave Pepper tries to blend into island life, pushing her high-end city lifestyle aside. Banding together with a few special local friends, most notable among them being the intrepid Damian Finch, Pepper must not only complete the daunting mission, but has to do so in short order, before everything comes crashing down. As Sessy’s only hope, Pepper is called on to make some tough decisions and comes face-to-face with moral dilemmas. Will her conscience allow her to do whatever is needed to stop the ruthless company? In the midst of all the chaos, Pepper allows feelings for Damian to overwhelm her emotions...and her heart. Is being with Damian in St. Kitts the dulcet life she’s always dreamed of?
B
25 votes

50%

AI Summary

We’re still gathering data. Your AI summary will be automatically generated after your poll completes, please check back in a few minutes.

Ask PickFu

Ask natural language questions about your poll to our custom AI engine. Don’t worry, it’s friendly.

Log in as poll owner to use Ask PickFu.
Response flags
0
Keywords
13
12
11
10


Gender identity
18
30
1
1
Age range
19
22
3
5
1
A
25 responses
A

I like a tropical beach island journey so this description is enticing.

A

More efficient messaging and to the point compared to the other option

A

A makes more sense to me

A

This text sounds much more exciting and interesting. The other option seems boring and I don't like it as much. Overall Option B is very lacking to me.

A

The style that A is written, at least for me, is easier to follow and get behind. B seems a bit wordy in unneeded ways.

A

Draws me in faster and is a shorter read. People won't read much of a description before moving on to the next one. Grab them quick and keep it very short.

A

I would buy option "A". The description looks appealing and interesting.

A

I like to get the name of the main character a lot sooner in the description

A

I went with A because paragraph B (starts with "on quiet...") has a run-on sentence right at the opening! Bad grammar = ugh no thanks

A

I prefer option A because it's a shorter but more concise description that gets the same points across as option B but in less words.

A

I got involved in the characters easily. Narrative is straightforward, without the fluff in B.

A

In my opinion, option A is more interesting and more well-written.

A

I chose panel A. I am originally from this area where the story is set and can relate to it well. I think it would be a good read as just this little bit, made me want to read more.

A

I would rather read A as it frames the storyline in a way that involves more intrigue and suspense (at least in my opinion).

A

I prefer option A. I felt like the description pulled me in a lot more and gave me plenty of background information at the beginning. B seemed like it took a little too long before getting into the meat of the plot and why I should read the book. I also felt like the writing was better and less overwhelming than option B. The sentences are simpler and more to the point in A.

A

The details of the description are favorable and I like how the story is progressing. Overall, the premise has sold me on the contents of the book going forward.

A

It tells you about the book the other choice makes you feel like you started reading the book in the middle

A

A is more interesting than B. But both of them share too much of the story! If this is for the flap or back cover, far too much has been given away. I don't want to know all the detail before I've actually read the book. But I do prefer knowing that Sessy is 89 and that's why her great niece is going in her place. I think these need to be rewritten to be short, pithy, intriguing without giving too much away, and highlight the Caribbean setting but don't tell us so much.

A

I liked that this option jumped into the character development more immediately so I could get a sense of Caroline's multifaceted personality right away.

A

I like option A better because it more intriguing.

A

this is easier to read and more succinct of a summary

A

Option A is shorter.

A

I think that option A has better flow and using a broad vocabulary. Option B is fine, just seems a little too simple and boring

A

I think it sounds more unique and engrossing.

A

This text is more direct and to-the-point. It sticks out and best entices me to want to read the book

B
25 responses
B

it goes into more detail and is longer

B

I like B because it sounds more romantic rather than historical.

B

slightly more of a description

B

I like choice B because it feels like there is a flow to the story rather than choice A which I felt took too much time trying to explain itself and setting up a background to the story but by then I lost interest.

B

Option b sounds more intriguing in my opinion

B

I like option B because it feels more descriptive and involving. Option A doesn't feel quite as connected and original to me.

B

I like how the excerpt on the novel in option B helped build the setting first when describing the scenario for Damian. I liked reading option B more than option A.

B

Choice B is my pick because I like how it jumps into focusing more on Pepper who is the main character of this story as opposed to going on about Sessy who is a secondary character. I also feel like Choice B goes more into the plot and the details behind how all of this will affect and change Pepper. That is why it interests me more and I would rather buy it.

B

Option B sounds way more adventures. I like the description of the characters and the story seems more vivid in my mind.

B

I like B because I like how it starts out with a story. It gets my attention with the first sentence.

B

The story sounds a lot more intriguing in option B

B

B sounds more interesting and adventure filled to me.

B

B seemed less stereotypical.

B

I think that option B does a better job of painting an interesting picture that I would actually want to read. Reading option A left me feeling confused and not that interested to read more to find out what is going on. Option B gave me the information I needed to already be pulled into the book and want to know more.

B

I like B's description better because A feels like it leads you on. Essentially, it makes you think that the main character is going to be "Sessy", so you're left with some disappointment after reading about "Sessy" in the first lines that she will be more of a background character.

B

I like option B because I like the way the book is described and I think that it makes the book sound more interesting.

B

This story seems a bit more relatable to me so I'd be more likely to choose this over the other option.

B

Option B is most catchy and easiest to understand

B

B sets ups this book with some mystery and intrigue and I’m interested. A is okay but not special.

B

it open up a lot better.

B

I like the description of option B more. It seems to flow better than option A. I am a little intrigued and want to know what is going to happen.

B

Option B has more of a suspenseful grab at the beginning of the summary. I am immediately intrigued by the offering. As a librarian and avid reader, this would quickly be added to my list.

B

I like choice B the most, especially because of the first few sentences which get me initially grabbed by the plot. it sounds like a story that is full of twists, action, and something I can sympathize with the character over.

B

This is a better description because I think it's a little more detailed and I like that it starts off with the phone call which is more attention grabbing and intriguing right off the start.

B

This is more anecdotal but I feel it works better because it builds suspense in a story format and makes you want to answer that question at the end by reading the book.

Subscribe to PickFu+ to unlock AI highlights on every poll.

Or, unlock AI features for this poll as a one-time $29 add-on.

AI analysis (sample data)

Unearth more insights with a detailed poll report, discovering what respondents liked, disliked, and what to do next.

Survey Analysis

Winning Option: Characteristics and Appeal

  • Option B emerged as the preferred brand packaging design, securing 12 out of 15 votes. Respondents frequently highlighted its aesthetic appeal, emphasizing the luxurious and high-quality impression it conveys. The ability to stack packages was a notable practical advantage mentioned by participants.
  • Several respondents appreciated the monochrome color scheme of Option B, which they found less overwhelming compared to more colorful designs. This preference for simplicity suggests that minimalistic designs may resonate well with this group.
  • Additionally, environmental considerations played a role in favoring Option B; some participants noted its reduced plastic usage and recyclability as attractive features.

Key Topics Across Options

  1. Aesthetic Appeal: Across both options, aesthetics were crucial in influencing preferences. Participants often referred to colors and overall design quality when justifying their choices.

  2. Environmental Concerns: Both options had respondents who valued environmentally friendly aspects of packaging. However, while Option A was praised for being reusable and eco-friendly by some, others perceived Option B’s reduced plastic use as more sustainable.

  3. Practicality: Practical elements such as ease of stacking (Option B) or suitability for travel (Option B) were significant factors in decision-making processes.

Hypotheses for Further Testing

  • Investigate whether minimalistic designs consistently outperform colorful ones across different demographic groups or product categories.

  • Explore if environmental messaging on packaging significantly influences consumer preference when compared with other attributes like luxury perception or practicality.

  • Assess how important stacking capability is relative to other functional benefits in various contexts such as home storage versus travel convenience.

These hypotheses can guide further research into understanding deeper consumer motivations behind packaging preferences observed in this survey context.

AI themes (sample data)

Learn what respondents like and dislike about your poll based on sentiments analyzed by our AI.
A

Likes (sample data)

  • Sleek and modern design
  • Large ear cup sizes for comfort
  • Minimalist and streamlined look

Dislikes (sample data)

  • Lack of unique features or standout elements
  • White color may get dirty easily
  • Not as much cushioning as other options
B

Likes (sample data)

  • (Note: There were no positive mentions specific to Option B in the provided survey answers)

Dislikes (sample data)

  • (Note: There were no negative mentions specific to Option B in the provided survey answers)
C

Likes (sample data)

  • Unique and stylish metallic grating design
  • Sturdy and flexible build
  • 'Cool' aesthetic appeal

Dislikes (sample data)

  • 'Weird' or unpleasant cone shape for earmuffs
  • 'Odd' overall appearance with metallic accents
  • (Note: Third negative mention not available from provided survey answers)
D

Likes (sample data)

  • Comfortable and sturdy design
  • Aesthetic appeal, including color options
  • Familiarity with the brand's quality

Dislikes (sample data)

  • Negative perception of the brand logo
  • Smaller ear size perceived as less comfortable
  • Design not preferred compared to others
E

Likes (sample data)

  • Sleek, modern, and professional look
  • Comfortable fit with larger ear sections that cup the ears well
  • Minimalist and clean black aesthetic

Dislikes (sample data)

  • 'Flat' appearance perceived as less comfortable by some
  • 'Bulky' design disliked by a few respondents
  • Narrower piece near headband' not appealing to all users
F

Likes (sample data)

  • 'Cushiony padding' for comfort over long periods of use
  • 'Solid build' making it durable and secure on the head/ears
  • Preferred neutral colors like black for headphones

Dislikes (sample data)

  • 'Large ear covering' may be too big for some users’ preferences
  • 'Separation of controls/buttons' not liked by everyone
  • 'Chrome accent rings on headband' not appealing to all respondents
G

Likes (sample data)

  • Design perceived as high quality and appealing
  • Liked the color, especially the blue
  • Thin padding was appreciated

Dislikes (sample data)

  • Looked flimsy to some respondents
  • Perceived as less sturdy compared to other options
  • Color preference for white or black over blue
H

Likes (sample data)

  • Modern and high-quality appearance with a white design
  • Comfortable padding on headband and ears
  • Sleek and neutral look preferred by many

Dislikes (sample data)

  • 'White' color seen as prone to getting dirty easily
  • 'Large ear cups' might be problematic for glasses wearers over long periods of use
  • 'Sturdy design' could be considered bulky by some users