I like option A the best and would click on it to buy it because I like that there is the "Assured Quality...." text and the American flag logo at the bottom of the package.

I like that this option is grain free, helps with canine dental health, and provides plenty of protein. I think that my dogs will like this and not fight the flavor.

I would choose option A because it looks like the healthiest option and has an emphasis on the ingredients being made with real chicken.

Option A is my first choice. The whole look is eye catching. The cute dog, the nice graphics and the vibrant color palette all make the option attractive and interesting. Options D & B are also quite nice and have a pleasing presentation that's quirky but cool. The last option looks a little dull, even the treats look dreary.

Options A and D with the dog faces and the packaging is very popping vibrant with contrasting colors makes it very appealing.

Option B is least favored because it is for large dogs only, otherwise all the products are good and option A is the best because it is a low calorie and grain free but high product very useful for dental health of the dog.

The wootsy brand name is cute along with the pup portrait for the treats in option A

The packaging is simple and the yellow banner tells me everything I need to know

I like the grain free. Nice little thing that ate it apart from the rest

I choose option A as my first choice because I Like the packaging of the product, and the image also shows the inner product along with the outer packaging.

Option a seems healthier for my dog fewer calories so i do not have to worry about his weight, is also the only product that is grain free incase the dog has allergies.

I like Option A best because of the dog model used on the packaging.

Option A is my first choice because the image shows the inner as well as outer packaging of the product. Moreover, I also see how many counts I get in a packet, and also the product is made by real chicken.

these are ranked from the healthiest looking to the least, option A looks the most eco friendly

The dog treat shown in option A has a lot of potential benefits that make me feel more connected with this brand because it can help my dog to have strong teeth, this food has low calorie in take and the amount of bones are good: 25 pieces.

Apart from the fact that the design is attractive, I also like the description of the product in option A. The design in option C is not appealing.

i chose option a because it offers more benefits for my dog

I would be more interested in buying the product shown in option A, because the package of this product have a really appealing presentation, also the fact that the treats are shown to the public with a really understandable explanation about its features and what does the treat have makes them more reliable to customers.

The dogs in these photos look happy and healthy.

I would pick A first because of the high protein.

I chose A and D first because the dogs looked cute on the package. And I chose B and C last because I can't see the dogs very well on those ones.

I love option A the most because it has the words dental health in the description making these the best for my dog.

I like that A refers to dental health.

Opiton "A": The physical look of the product is much more appealing comparatively while the "grain free" benefit makes this the better purchase choice.

I think the purple catches your attention first.

Option A is the most visually appealing and grabs your attention more right off the bat. I think they more like something my pet would enjoy and the design makes me think they would last longer. I think the wording is stronger and gives you a better idea of what you are getting for them and what they can for your animal. They have a more professional and advanced look to them that gives you more confidence that they are high quality and would be more beneficial for your dog. Option A would appeal to more people and would make them more likely to check deeper into what they have to offer.

Choices A and B look to include actual meat that my dogs would probably love, so I would go with either of those.

I would love to buy option A dog treat. By its description and packaging colors, design, it seems the best option to me, I am sure my dog will absolutely love it.

I chose option a first because it is grain free and high protein. Option c was next because it mentions that it is real chicken which i would prefer. Option d is next because i liked that they were mini treats and option b was last because training treats doesnt really appeal to me.

I will start with saying I would not buy B and D, these are brands I am familiar with. A and C were new brands that seemed healthier so I would give those a shot with my dog. A looked a little more natural to me

the mini chews look too small and like a choking hazard

I honestly ranked based on package design and the cuteness of the dogs.

Option A because description was the most informative

The first one says it's for dental hygeine. All others do not. The second one says it's raw hide free (whatever that means and why this is important I don't know). I chose 2 because those chews remind me of what chews I'd buy my dog and there is a count.

I would like to buy option A as my preference. From the image , we get to know the count and also dog treats looks good compared to others.

A is the best because it supports dental health and is grain free

I like A and B because I can see the product out of the package

I like the look and wording of the bones in A the best

I like A the best, the bones on the outside of the bag are enticing and I like the packaging of choice D.

I prefer a first, because I think the dog on the picture is very cute

The dog looks to be really enjoying them.

Option B looks tasty for dogs, beneficial, and it also has a great overall design.

I chose the one I did because they are the biggest. I have a bigger dog. These treats come with size ratings that correspond to how big your dog is due to choking hazards. The rest of my choices also prioritized size, and what my dog tends to like.

I would probably click on all of them just to see where they are made. I don't give my dogs anything but things specifically saying "MADE IN THE USA" not produced or manufactured but MADE. My dog got violently sick once when I gave him something that was made in another country and I can't go through that again.

C's packaging colors felt too dull to me. I liked that B's brighter colors make the treats look more zesty and flavorful.

I have 3 dogs, two little and one middle size. They are not very good about chewing bones, but they like the bones with chicken or other meat around the edges. Choice B is the best one for them. Same with Choice A. Choices C and D do not have meat around the edge so I would be less likely to purchase for them.

Choices B and A first because they are more pleasing to me and they do show the contents of the product much better as compared as compared to choices D and C for me.

I prefer option B because to me it looks the most delicious and scrumptious. Option D and A feel very enticing as well. Option C looks the least interesting to me.

My dog really loves the jerky wrapped around her rawhide, so I would be drawn to B and A.

I picked Option B because it doesn't mention rawhide. Rawhide is bad for dogs.

The chews look great and you can easily see them

I like how you can get a good look at the bone in option B.

It's the only option that is for large dogs. The other 3 options are mini bones for small dogs and I won't give those to my medium sized dog.

Good ingredients, good brand reputation

I have only slight preferences of one option over the other and thus in a normal situation might just pick which is cheapest by volume. I prefer that B and A both show the chews outside the package. B looks like it has more seasoning on the chews which a dog might enjoy more. C looks like a more healthy option but bland.

Looks like they have extra flavor and would be tasty for my pup

I like that B and A show the actual product outside of the packaging so they can be examine in size, shape, etc. C is a reputable and well known brand for quality. D has informative and insightful detailed information. All of these options look like something that my dog would enjoy. I would buy any of these!

Option B is my first choice for the dog treat because it shows the contents of the package in the display which makes it more easy to decide over the other options.

I would choose Option B, they look the best and it is the only option that mentions it is for large dogs. I have an 80 pound dog so for sure I would choose this one. Option D is the worst, they just look plain and milk bone is kind of low budget.

The design and colors are fun, and the product looks large next to its packaging.

Option B - My dog is big. He needs something that will allow him to really get chewing out of his system and this looks like a good product for that. Option C is the next largest product, which also happens to look well made. It's also a product my dogs have tried before and loves. Option A I don't think will appeal to my current dog much, but it will keep him entertained for a bit. Option D is too small, which means my dog would choke on it. I wouldn't purchase it.

I like the image of the bones they look very appetizing

B because it advertises being long lasting. I have seen dogs woof down treats in a second so that to me isn't a treat unless it can keep the dog entertained and working on the treat. A next because 9f the health benefits it advertises. C was last because of the mini size.

Kindly note that my rankings are purely arbitrary/random, as I would not buy *any* of the products shown. None of them is vegan, hence I could not buy it--I can't even PRETEND to do it, that's how strongly against animal cruelty I am, and these products definitely involved animal cruelty in their production.

Like the real rawhide for started. Then the image and the description on the package looks the best.

Option B looked like it was the largest and the most flavorful, Option C Looked the smallest and least flavorful

Option D and C are mini, so they would be too small for my dog. Plus, I like the meat in the middle of B and A.

B looks like it would keep my dog occupied the longest, which is a goal of mine for my active dog. D and C I am familiar with the brands and I like them.

Option B looks to be a good quality product and option D is a brand that I know so I might go with that as well.

I like the color and from the appearance it looks like it tastes good for the dog

I would pick B as my favorite because I feel it gives you the best of both. I also like that it shows what you are buying outside the package. Usually I would like the dog in it with D but it’s a bit hard to see.

I like B and A best, I like the physical design of the treat, they appear more natural and have real meat in them.

I have larger dogs and option B stood out to have larger sized bones. I also like how they seem to be wrapped in meat, I think my dogs would be able to spend a good amount of time snacking on them.

I like how these bones are shown in the picture, as well as they look more appealing than the other ones

I like the packaging of B best, I like the name of D best.

I like that option C and D are raw hide free, these will be a lot easier on my dog's stomach. I like the smart bones brand in option C and I can trust they have a good product.

C is the brand my dog likes and the one I already buy for him, so I was drawn to that option first. I would never buy Milk Bone because he doesn't like them, so I ranked D last

Simply because I don't like to give my dog rawhide. I ranked them in order of how much rawhide I felt was in them based on the packaging.

I want a smart dog and I like the upscale packaging, so I'm going with Option C.

I would get rawhide free first, because they are safer. I'd choose milkbone second because it's a trusted name to me that I've felt was ok for years.

I would like to buy option C product. Because this product give 32 mini chews with free dog chew treat.

I prefer option C because it looks like it would be easy for my dog to chew and digest. I also like that it is made with chicken and vegetables this makes me feel good knowing my dog has a healthy snack.

I like C because I don't like giving my dog rawhide and this is the only option that's rawhide free. I chose B next because I have a large dog. D over A because I recognize D's brand name.

I ranked in the order that I felt I was getting the most amount of product, to limit the times I have to go back and buy more.

I like the shape and size of the bones. That it is no rawhide. Plus I like the simple packaging.

I would be most likely to purchase option C because I think that it has the most premium and visually appealing packaging design out of the four options above.

I chose C because I like that it is made with real chicken and that it is named smart bones. I like that.

option C and A look like healthier options for dog treats. They don't look as plastic looking. I would go with those

I have ranked all the above 4 options as per their composition and found option C product which is rawhide free easily digestible chews full of Vitamins and minerals.

SmartBones sounds nice. The Jungle Calling name seems super weird to me.

I like this one it tells me how many are in the packaging and it tells me what they are made of I would buy these

I prefer option C. I like that they are real chicken and rawhide free.

I like the first two options because they offer more treats

B is last as this one is too bright and feels fake to me and I want something more natural feeling for my dog. I love C a lot as it feels natural and clean for me. From there, I like A over D as D is too bright for me

I would look into C, because it's raw-hide free, seems really natural, and nice and chewy for my pet.

C... The first thing I saw was no rawhide So that definitely draws me to it more so than the others and the color of the packaging is appealing. Made with real chicken Is also in the center and easier for me to see

I like option C the best. I think smart bones would be great for my dog. they have real chicken and they have a great star rating. I would buy these

Option C looks the most "straight to the point" while other options are just cheesy

I prefer rawhide free, so C and D were my top two choices, and I preferred the packaging on C.

I wouldn't buy milk-bones on Amazon because I can get those at the store. C & A looked the most reputable.

C looks like a healthy choice without all of the artificial colors. I wouldn't typically choose A or B.

I would never buy option D mil-bone. I would rather purchase option C because it is made with real chicken.

Option C is my top choice as I like the simple design on this bag, it looks more like a natural product and just better designed. Options A and B are virtually tied for second as I like the way that the bones are featured on the outside of the package - this lets me get a peek at what I'm buying. And finally option D is last as it's just not as visually appealing as the other options.

I'd go with C first, I like that it is made with real chicken and is rawhide free, that is very important for giving my dog.

This product comes with more treats.

c a and b show the product better so i have a better idea of what i am getting. d colors distract from the product and the product window is too small to see what it is like.

Option C would be the only product I would choose because it is rawhide free and I do not give my dog rawhide.

I prefer C as it has real chicken and is the most natural.

just enough to give the dog a little treat sometimes without spoiling their dinner

Option C seems the most authentic and beneficial to the dog.

C and D look very similar to me. Since there is no price, I just went with them being the same price, so I went with the 32 count. I like them because they are both rawhide free and made with real chicken. A and B are last because they are rawhide. I went with A over B because it has the assured US quality.

I picked C first because it has no rawhide and is made with real chicken, I picked D next because it also is free from rawhide and the brand is one that I recognize. I picked A next because it is grain free and B last because it is for large dogs and it has beefhide.

I prefer option C because they are free of rawhide.

I would buy smaller ones because I have smaller dogs

Option C has real chicken in them. The rest just say "chicken".

Info on the packaging, reviews, quantity, and overall how safe and effective they would be.

I would chose Option C Smart Bones for my labrador. I have used this product before and my dog loves it. I would not give my dog either of the rawhide treats as they do not digest easily.

Option c has real chicken so that would be my first option. Both options c and d are smaller treats and would seem to be better able to be chewed and not cause digestive troubles compared to the final two.

The Smartbones looks the nicest in design here. Good to see inside the packaging. Nicely put together for the brand. I like the Wootsy brand as well. Nice look and design for this. Looks great. Jungle calling isn't bad here either. Think Milk Bone is tried and true but a bit boring.

The design of the package looks the best and most trustworthy in C.

I'd buy the two rawhide-free options. Rawhide gives my dogs stomach problems.

Rawhide free is my best option. I dont have to worry about the dog digesting pieces of rawhide

C would be my first choice because it is rawhide free. It also is made of real chicken which sounds healthier than the others.

Chose the treats that included real meat first and then followed up with the treats that i think would be most beneficial for my dog

I would only really consider c the others appear cheap and not sustainable, doesn't look too healthy for my dog

I chose this option because I prefer rawhide free and I thought they look like a good option

I would choose C as it looked like the simplest option and easiest to eat for my dog.

Option C is made with real chicken and are rawhide free. This is much better for my dog.

I don't give my dogs rawhide and would want the rawhide free options.

I'm not sure that I like the name of the last two in particular however Milk Bone I know but they tend not to be that healthy. I want to make sure that my dog has a nice natural treat that there's lots of them in it and that it's going to last him a little while. I wish I knew how many were in number one but those look like great treats

Option C looks like the most high-end product with the best ingredients. It is easy to read and visualize. Option D is only because I know dogs love the milkbone brand and you can't go wrong there. Option B doesn't have the best packaging and it doesn't highlight the product well. Option A I am indifferent about.

C is my number one choice because based on the packaging, it looks the healthiest. D is next because I usually don't have a lot of time to browse or peruse options when shopping, and I find it very direct, to the point, and appealing. Next comes A, but it is ranked lower because the purple background color doesn't attract my attention as much. B is last because it looks cheap to me, and the image of the dog is small. Most pet stores sell treats for dogs AND cats, and I hate having to take extra time to make sure I am buying treats for the right species.

I think these would be ok for the boys because they are rawhide free and have real chicken in it.

C and D are the best option because they are rawhide freeB and A I chose on the size of the bones

I love the look of the cute dog in option D, so that is the one I would choose.

Because I have experience with milk bone, I know that they're reliable and my dog enjoys them.

I chose option D. I like the size of each of the knotted bones. This would help with her teeth as well as keep her busy for a while.

The packaging of options D and B are really cute with the dog faces plus the color combination used to design it are very impressive.

I really like the dog with the bone in his mouth on D.

i would not buy any rawhide bones because my dog does not like them

Option D because of the packaging that has better readable text and less crowded design

B looks cheap. D is a brand I know. A looks less cheap than C.

I think the dog looks the cutest on this one. That is important. It is a very eye catching design. I like the color scheme too

I don't give my dog rawhide, so I would choose D or C. I would slightly prefer D because of the name brand

I know this brand and like it. I also like the packaging- the dog looks happy.

i would be most likely to buy the treat in option D because it looks tasty and healthy for a dog

top choice actually shows a dog actively enjoying the product 2nd choice has a dog on the cover

I've heard of the milk bone brand before. I would buy from a company I know and trust.

I would buy D because its a brand I know and trust. Its a brand I buy today

I think option D is the most attention grabbing and easiest to read which makes me the most likely to buy

I like D the most because of brand recognition. Option C seems a little more natural to me than the other two. Options A and B seem really processed and I worry about the ingredients in the treats.

D is a brand I recognize and I am familiar with. A is made in the USA so I'm more comfortable with it. I do not recognize B or C.

I find the MilkBone brand to be very trustworthy so Option D would be my first choice. I also like both Options D & C because they mention "rawhide-free" on the bags.

Yes, to Milk Bone. D is my top pick because this brand has been trusted by me for my poochies for decades. This is a great product that my pups love!

I would most likely pick D because I know Milk Bone brand and trust them. outside of that I prefer no rawhide that is why I picked C. A has no grain and I am hit and miss with that promise. Something about B reminds me of dollar general food and I would stay clear of that

D I know the name and I like the colors and the packaging. I like the image. AI like the blue packaging and the image. C I like the packaging colors and style. B I don't like the image of the listing. The packaging is ok.

I ranked these based on the brand names that were most familiar to me.

I love and trust Milkbones and the company that makes them. My dog loves them. A is next because it is low calorie and supports my dogs teeth health. C is great with saying real chicken added. B is for large dogs and I don't have large dogs

I trust this brand and have used them before, but I would not buy raw-hide treats very often.

I prefer Option D because I am familiar with the brand and I doubt the product would make my dog sick.

I like the dog treat packaging with the cute faces of the dogs enjoying the treats since these are dog treat packages I would prefer seeing a dog on the label.

I know and trust the brand in Option D and I heard rawhide is not healthy for a dog's digestion so Options A and B are out for me.

D is a known brand that is trustworthy.C seems like a brand that I have seen before.A has a nice name so I would try it out.B looks like a treat my dog would really enjoy.

i like choice D the best cause i like the brand the most. i havent heard of the other brands so im not sure about them

Been a customer of Milkbones for decades and never had any issue with treats they make. So, I'd probably stick with them and chose D.

I prefer option d and b more than the others because it contains more information about thr product and looks more trustworthy. Option c and b are okay also but the it does nit look that appealing

I chose option D first because it is a name brand I recognize and have used their products before without issues. Option C came next due to the fact that it was the only other choice that was rawhide free. Options B and A are last to me because they both contain rawhide. If I want to give my dog rawhide, I will buy it separately.

I think D has the best label and the best looking product.I think the product in B looks repulsive and artificial, I would not feel good about feeding it to my dog

I prefer this option because I am familiar with the brand and the packaging looks most like one I can trust for my dog.

I chose by options that most are or resemble brands I know and have come to trust.

MilkBone is a brand I know and trust so I would choose D first. A I like the look of the bag and the yellow block information also makes me trust it. C the bag looks plain in design and at the colors all kind of blend in together. In B it looks too artificial and too many bad ingredients with all the bright colors in the treats and packaging, would not trust it for my dog.

There are two things in particular that I really like about this product, I really like the color combination of red and green, I think it’s really attractive. I also really like the little dog in the front, he looks really happy and healthy, which is exactly how I would want my dog to be if I give them this product.

I would purchase option D because they are the only brand on this list I have seen before. This mean's I trust it more.

I chose option D first, because I am more familiar with that brand and would be more comfortable purchasing this product from a reliable company. I then ranked the other based on count number. Option B did not have those details so it was ranked 4th.

I'd be most likely to buy D because I'm familiar with the brand.

I think that the dog image on package D just looks cute.

I would rather not have the rawhide, and I know and trust this brand.

I would pick option D. This is because I’m most familiar with the Milk Bone brand.

I ranked my preferences based on the types of treats that my dog tends to enjoy more

I would buy Option D. The rawhide-free aspect is very important. I like the bright design of the bag.

D because they are rawhide free and from a trusted brand

Im familiar with D so i would go with that . A sounds the most trustworthy with the US tag line and B looks a bit more trustworthy than C.

I like the ones with a picture of the dogs on the packaging. I picked them from the order of which ones I thought were the cutest

Without doing research on the brands milkbone would be the one I go for. It is a brand that I know my dog can have and the vet says it is safe. The rest I would need to research the brands well and their ingredients before considering. If we pretend I have done that much research and know all the brands I would go with jungle next because of size. The other two I am indifferent on

My dog loves milk bone stuff, so I'd just go with the stuff I know my dog loves! They all look fine, but I just go with the one that's priced right that my dog enjoys.

Rawhide free and I know the brand

D. Honestly its the brand that sells me. They are trusted in my household to provide quality products.

Option D because of the brand name and the packaging design. Option B is good because you can see what the treat looks like and the package design.

I like the image of the dog chewing on the bone in choice D. that makes the product look fun and I could picture my dog chewing it

I chose D first because I'm familiar with the brand and it is rawhide-free. I chose C second because it is rawhide-free. I chose B third and A fourth because they have rawhide.

D was a Milk Bone product a known brand that my dog has enjoyed in the past clearly listed flavor and number of chews. A gave an extremely detailed description of the product with 5 descriptors and the number of chews inside. B the number of chews inside the package wasn't included in the description but I liked that they said if was for large dogs so a small dog owner wouldn't buy it. C the product looked artificial without realistic colors.

There are more chews in the D (30) and I am familiar with the milkbone brand, which I know will be reasonably priced.

I'm most familiar and have used the Milkbone and the dogs love it.

Option D looks very wholesome and trustworthy. I would imagine e that this product would more likely have better and healthier ingredients than the competition because of that.

After carefully studying and comparing all four images of dog treats displayed above and on Amazon, I selected Option D as my first preference and the one that I would definitely click on to purchase for my own dog Bella. I felt that this image just jumped right out at me as having the most eye catching appeal based on the attractive design and bright coloring. Option A was my second choice followed by Option B and finally Option C with all four rankings based on the overall attractiveness of each product image.

as a dog owner i do like when there is a dog on the packaging but for this i went with what looks the best to me and imagined it on my store shelf so choice d and a were my favorites.

D is the only one I would buy because it's the only brand that I recognize. I chose the other three in order of the package design. I also like that B says it's for large dogs. I chose A on the package alone. And C just looks boring.

I would choose Option D because I know "Milk Bone" to be a reputable brand name that I feel is healthier for my dog. I like Option C second best because it is "rawhide-free." I do not like Options A and B because they are rawhide which may be harmful to dogs.

I would choose Option D. Milk-Bone is a brand I know and that has a good reputation. I would choose them to make sure my dog was getting the best.

I put the dog treats in D, A, B and C order. I really like D. D is my favorite. I trust D. I'm very familiar with the dog treat brand for D.