App Icon Test Marketing Poll

50 Respondents General Population

This is a completed app icon test marketing poll.

The mobile app developer received 50 unbiased responses (votes & explanations) from the general population in about 18 minutes.

Using PickFu, mobile app developers are able to test app icons and screens before launching.

Test Your Own App Icons 

Poll Results

 Dec 9, 2014
 Public
Question

Which of the middle fypio app icons do you like more?

50 RespondentsGeneral Population

Option A


Score: 69.1
38 votes
Option B


Score: 21.8
12 votes

Responses 
Showing 50/50 responses

38 Responses to Option A
1
prefer that design
2
The heart looks weird when it expands past the border
3
I love how the blue and pink look crossed like that.
4
liked it better
5
This one looks better
6
I like the smaller heart.
7
I think the icons on option A are easier to see.
8
prefer the diagonal colors
9
Sounds better
10
A is a little more eye-catching
11
I don't like the huge heart.
12
The superimposed heart is just too much in B
13
I like the gradient background more than the heart
14
I'm not thrilled with the heart.
15
its neater looking. the other one looks sloppy
16
I tend to like icons that are less flashing and use more straight lines.
17
i think that i stands out more. also i like the heart above the house
18
I think the Option A icon looks more modern and fits in better with the rest of the iPhone.
19
The heart on Choice B dominates and little focus is on the house. Choice A has a better balance between the house and the heart.
20
the other one looks cramped
21
I just think it looks better
22
A looks more like other icons on screen - more uniform
23
It looks a bit classier and adult like.
24
Looks more professional.
25
Really stands out!
26
Almost identical. Option A is more readable.
27
It looks much more tidy and neat and looks better with the other icons around it.
28
They look the same except the middle icon. But I like this one best.
29
I like this option the best. It looks more quaint and has more appeal to me.
30
B just looks like a big heart at the first glance. Not as suitable.
31
Not much difference but this stands out.
32
they both were equally nice
33
I don't like the giant heart on option B.
34
less girly
35
Im not a fan of having hearts as my app picture. Choice A is more simple and looks better without a heart
36
not to girly
37
It looks cleaner to me. More stylish
38
Option A looks more professional/like something I would take more seriously. Option B just looks like a dating app.
12 Responses to Option B
1
The shading in Option A reminds me of something from the 80s. Option B is a little too childish, but it is better.
2
I found it more appealing.
3
big heart is cuter
4
Just caught my eye more
5
Option B has less red in the background image, which makes it more pleasant on the eyes.
6
It's less jarring than A. Aesthetically, it's more pleasing.
7
I think B looks cute with the heart.
8
I would much prefer B over A as it seems more unique and fun.
9
i pay more attention to this one
10
I like the icons and colors for each app better, as well as the arrangement.
11
I like that one better.
12
This seems like a more unique app icon. I like it more than the other.

Demographics

Age Range
Gender
Loading