I like that option A has the god smiling and happy to be looking at the treats

This one clearly stood out to me. Very easy to tell the flavor and the kind of treat that the product has.

I prefer option A because it looks like it is the healthiest and it is made with real chicken. It also looks like it would be the safest treat for my dog because it is not too sharp and it doesn't have added colors.

Overall this packaging is the most attractive and attention grabbing in my opinion

Option B and Option D seem to have a lot of sharp, ragged edges from the coating. Option A or Option C seems a bit safer for my dog.

The dog on the front is the cutest. But also I like the name Wootsy. Dream Bond would be my second.

Option a tells me the product is grain free which is great if your pet has allergies also this is a treat i can give my dog even if the dog is to heavy because the snack is low calorie. This is also the healthiest choice of all the options.

The dog is really cute and memorable for option A, as is the name. D looks really outdated.

A the american assured part sounds weird and i really dont trust any of them but i did rank them on which looked more professional.

Option A is the most visually appealing and grabs your attention more right off the bat. I think the wording is stronger and tells you more about what the product can do for your pet and seems more beneficial. It has a good look for something like this and matches up more with my idea of a dog treat. I also think it gives you more confidence that the product is high quality and would be better for your animal. Option A would appeal to more people and would make them more likely to check deeper into what it has to offer.

I like the packaging with the more cute and happy dogs on the cover, they look like they are enjoying these dog treats and I think my dog would also enjoy these treats just like these smiling pups!

As a result of the product's very intriguing features, which create the sense that it is high quality, option A' is my top pick.

Option A claims to be it is good for dental health so putting them on top rank. Other options are ranked respectively of my preference.

I like this one it is grain-free and high in protein, I like the way it stands out to me and has an easy to read the packaging

A.. with the American flag logo it's telling me the product is made or sourced in the USA ... And that's the only one out of the out of all the others that show that....so i'd lean more towards this one for sure

I would pick this one for Teresa’s, I really like the description of the product on this label, and I also like the little dog that they put on there, he looks really cute and happy, and it kind of reminds me of my own dog

The cute dog face on the front of the package in Option A grabs my attention right away, as does the display of vertical treats to the right of the bag. Next, I like how there is a display of treats horizontally in front of the package in Option D.

I chose A because It says its assured quality with USA Guidelines.

I prefer option A. My dog would prefer all chicken treats.

I ranked based on how well I could see the actual treats in each image

Option A looks good. I'm sure my dog would love munching on Wootsy Chicken Wrapped Rawhide sticks. So, yeah, option A would be the one I'd buy. I'm sure my dog would find them to be very tasty.

I ranked in the order that I think my dog would like the design, and that I felt reassured by the description.

I think option A looks good. The dog on the packaging looks happy and cute

I chose A because it says it is high-protein. That's good and I like that it has a dog on the package.

A is my first choice because it states that it is good for dental hygiene which is important to me for my dog. Option C seems like it would contain contains more because they measured by product count and not weight. Option B states that it is gluten free, opposed to D which does not give me much information about the product l.

The package in A has the best design.

I would choose choices A and D first because they are more visually pleasing to me and attractive to me as compared to choices B and C for me.

A is the best because i can easily see on the front what it's offering and the look of the product. The rest of them don't give me any confidence of the quality of the product or a desire to buy them.

Choice A shows more benefits to the treat.

For me, I love A and B as they feel fun but also natural to me and not as intense as D and C which feel like too much for me. I love A the most as this is bright and fun and feels like something I want to feed to my dog.

I picked them based on which ones used ingredients or excluded ingredients that would be healthier for my dog. I also picked them based on the best package and product design

These are all very similar pet products, so I chose the one with the cutest dog on the package.

top choice has a real picture of an actual dog on the label cover

A. I love the cute dog and the green color scheme. B is nice and clean and the beige color makes it feel more natural. C is nice but i feel red is a common and generic dog treat color. D. same about the color but I don't like the Jungle Calling name as much because it's just chicken so it doesn't really make sense to me.

My eyes are drawn to the picture of the dog. It's cute and looks appealing

Ranked based on how premium and inviting the product packaging looks.

I like A and D because they contain chicken

All the treats seem appetizing for my dogs, but my dogs have some dental issues so that was my first choice and instinct. Anything to help their teeth and gums is always a plus.

I prefer the option A dog treat product listing because I like the low calorie treat the most. I chose options C and D second and third because I like the large count packaging more than the training treats design. I chose option B last because there is no dog shown on the product packaging and the packaging is a smaller size.

Option A because it supports dental health and is low calorie.

I chose A because I like the dog as you immediately now these are dog treats. B was next as it says Pet C was next as it says DreamBone so I sort of knew more what it was. D was last as Jungle Calling seems very odd for a dog treat name. I just barely noticed the dog after looking many times. Seeing the dog easier and moving the stick in front of the pkg would probably help on this one.

I found option A to look the most appealing and high quality that I think my dogs would enjoy while being healthy for them. I like when the product is visible on the packaging so you know what to expect.

I would choose A and B first because they look the most healthy and ecofriendly based on the packaging. C and D remind me of lower level treats that could harm your dogs health.

The colors of the packaging got my attention on option A.

The dog's face on label A is really cute so I like this label the best.

Option "A": This graphics package, label clarity and wonderful use of an animal to make it easy to remember, this is the better presentation comparatively.

I like the first choice, A, since it looks the most natural for my dog. I do not want to give them that has been processed with chemicals like the last option C.

All of these are pretty dangerous for dogs but I feel like with a I'd be able break it into very small pieces

I would like this one because of stating it supports dental health.

i went with what sells, cover photos are important

I like A the most and would be most likely to click it to look at it in more depth. I like that the info provided on the thumbnail has the health benefits up front and that is something I find encouraging to lean more about.

I based my choice off what I felt would be healthiest for my dog. I do not by treats with rawhide

I choose choice A because it mentions low calorie and dental health which are very important to me. I choose B second because I like the natural aspect of them. D looked more processed and C looked very unhealthy and processed with no real benefit.

Having a dog on the packaging is important so I wouldn't pick B. I think A fits the best because it has the bigger picture of the dog. It makes this packaging stand out a lot more compared to others. I think D is also a good option because I like that it has a good look at the treat for the dog outside the packaging.

After carefully studying and comparing all four images of dog treats displayed above and on Amazon, I selected Option A as my first preference and the one that I would most likely click on to purchase for my own dog Bella. Given that all star ratings and number of customer reviews were similar or the same, I felt that Option A had the most eye catching appeal to me based on the cute dog in the image and the bright coloring accompanying the image. Option B was my second choice followeds by Option D and finally Option C with all four rankings based on my own personal opinion of the relative attractiveness of each product image.

I would like to buy to option A, because this product is best for pets dental health and also high in protein.

I like the happy dogs on the packaging, but had B had a happy dog on it, it would be the best. I like the chicken theme

I would buy option A because of the "assured quality USA" statement at the bottom of the package makes me feel better knowing that the rawhide sticks are made with ingredients that are safe for my dog.

A is my first choice because on the package it says Made in the USA. I probably wouldn't purchase one of the others.

A looks less processed and healthy

I prefer Option B because it states that it is for a small dog, which I have, and it is a large bag.

i thin the presentation of the product in choice b looks great. it makes the product within the package look far more appealing.

B seems the most natural and pet health friendly.

The dog in Option A looks ugly and looks like the type of dog that could bite. It goes last. I like it when I can inspect the dog treat from outside the package because the packaging is clear. For that reason I have Option B first. Option B actually has clear packaging while Option C doesn't, but I just think the design in Option C is better than Option B. The dog in Option C is cuter and the textual design is larger, clearer, and more attractive.

The packaging in Option B looks the most appealing and feels the most natural with its colors and font.

The coloring of the package of B makes it feel more natural and safe. Then C is cute with the little sleeping dog. I feel like A and D are too much with the coloring and design.

I would be more inclined to purchase this option because the packaging is more appealing and looks to be of higher quality.

I really like the packaging design in B, I think it looks more natural and higher quality than the other choices

honestly i wouldnt but anything with rawhide but, looking at them B is the most attractive it gives the person a sense of natural and better quality for the consumer.

I really like the look of B, because it looks to be the most natural and organic product out of these choices. And, they seem the safest for my pet.

I would buy Option B because the clear bag lets me see the quality of the product. I like that it looks as thought there's a lot of meat on each stick.

I chose by options with a most simple look as I would want something that is more gentle and natural for my pet.

Without knowing the prices or any of the reviews, I ranked my choices based on how natural the dog chews looked. I try not to give my dog too much human or bad food/treats. I think option B would be the first product I click on to learn more about.

I chose the products that I think my pet would like the most and picked my favorite images from them.

It seems like it will have the most in the pack since it's a full 16 ounces. Option A doesn't have the weight listed at all. Option B has a nice natural color packaging and it looks like the chicken covers the rawhide well.

I would choose B the packaging looks more professional and premium.

b and c have very muted colors that give the feeling that it is more natural and better for your pet. a and d have a brighter more busy look to the packaging that give it a feeling that it might contain unnatural ingredients and coloring that could be harmful to my pup

I would choose option B because the packaging promotes clean and natural ingredients.

I like to see the product and B does that and what I see looks simple and wholesome.

I went with the overall bag design on this one I really like how option b has more of a contemporary look to the packaging. The others I just ranked in order of the bags I liked best to least.

I like the white label it looks perfect so option B is my top choice

Option B because the packaging is more minimalist and looks very cute for dog treat

Clearest packaging, option B allows me to see just about every inch of the treats and not just a tiny window like the other options.

judging by its features option B looks the healthiest out of all the choices and i love its eco friendly design

I think the natural colors of this packaging fit well with what the product is. It looks like good quality, and I like the green color usage, it suggests being natural. Option C also has the green color, that I think works for this product being a natural product. It's a cute dog as well. I don't like red for this product for some reason. The words Dream Bone on option A look like a cheesy font. I dislike the word jungle in this day and age. It feels dated.

Option B looks the best and the most natural option of all the products. Option A is the most unappealing, the dog on the package looks unhappy.

look the most natural and the most like what dogs should be eating

I would check out B because it appears to have a lot of meat (chicken) wrapped around the stick. I like the smaller size because I have a small dog (10 lbs) and these are the perfect size for her.

I like the natural look and description of option B. It seems to be the most true to advertisement of all of them. the product looks nice as well

I chose this because I could see the actual product and I thought it would be the most enjoyed option of them all by my pet

Option B is displaying the best dog treat product and it makes me think that my dog would love it. It has a good description.

The packaging in B looks the most natural to me and good.

I would choose option B first beause they seem the most natural and I want to feed natural safe products to my dog.

Based on package descriptions, Option B seems the healthiest, but not really sure. Made subsequent choices using the same logic.

C made my dog sick so I would never buy them again.

I particularly like the packaging on the first one I think it's a little bit more unique and I think it also makes it seem more natural the brown and green give me more of an earthy feel to it and I really want my dog to have Natural Treats I do like number two and number three but they feel more processed which I don't want

Each of these look very tasty. I think the package looks best for option B in the Pet n' Shape brand. Looks nice and very tasty. Option C is great too with DreamBone. Good design for the package and nice chicken strips. Option D is also not bad here. Think that is nice for the Jungle Calling brand. Option A with Wootsy is not bad but less interesting packaging if you ask me.

I choose B first because they are small.

I ranked my choices based on which product packaging makes the product look like it is made with natural ingredients. I think that makes the food more healthy. I try to give my pets healthy foods.

I like the look and texture of B and D and that they are for small dogs.

These look the most natural and safe.

chicken fully wrapping the stick is a must

The natural choice catches my attention more than the others. I would hope this would mean it did not have a lot of fillers or other junk in it. I would be even more drawn to it if it had organic ingredients and were shown to be made in the USA. But my first two choices would be a better choice and my first selection would be the one that I would likely choose.

I would be most likely to purchase option C because I think that it has the most eye-catching and visually appealing packaging design out of the four options above.

I like the red packaging. It has the best look in my opinion.

I like Option C because it looks the tastiest and like my dogs would love to have them!

Option C has the best packaging design.

C looks like the best one to me. I like the name and the package.

I like that these are raw hide free.

I have experience with Dream Bone brand so I know I can trust their product.

I liked C cause there are 50 in each bag.,

i would buy the dog treat in option C because it looks like the healthiest option to me

I really like the name of this product; I think it sounds very appealing. I also like that it is made with chicken. I think that would appeal to my dog very much.

I would only choose C - they are the only ones that are rawhide free - rawhide is not good for dogs.

C is the only one I would buy. No rawhide for my pups, it's bad for them

C looks nutritious and a treat my dog would enjoy. I can see the chickenB & A also look good. The chicken is visible and looks like fun to chewA does not look appetizing even though the packaging is better than the rest. The chicken looks very thin and not very appealing

I chose Option C as I have used this product before and my dog loves it. I also do not give my dog rawhide products since they are not easily digestible and this is rawhide free.

All the options have been ranked based on the quantity from the most to the least preferred.

All the options are ranked from the most to the least preferred on the basis of the quantiities.

These look more tasty and I like the name of the treats.

The Jungle Calling seems weird on Option D. I liked Option C the best because it seems a bit more normal and the Dreambone name is good.

I would go with this option because I've given my dog similar products in the past and he seemed to like them.

These all look equally preferable to me so I made my choices based on how much I felt I was getting out of each product. I liked how C and a told me exactly how many treats were in each bag rather than the weight.

C seems like it would last the longest, based on appearance. The other three are fairly equal to me.

I like that it is not rawhide, although I would want to know what it was.

C seems like the thicker of these dog treats, which is good for a dog like mine who like to chew hard on their treats and makes it last a little longer.

I ordered my choices from least generic looking to most generic looking.

C. looks tasty from a dog's perspectiveA. doesn't look as nice but I think they'd still like itB. kinda okay I guess, not thrilledD. the white part looks weird

I choose this one as it is rawhide free, I will not purchase an item with rawhide.

i chose option c because they are rawhide free and safer for my dog to digest

I do not give my dog rawhide treats, they are very bad for him. So C is my only choice here.

I would buy C on Amazon because it has an attractive package and the description is what I am looking for for my pooch.

I like C or D the most. I think they look like premium treats that would be healthy for my dog.

I like the packaging design the most on the first one I chose so that would entice me to buy it

I would go with C because of its claims of using real chicken and not using rawhide, both are important to me and my dogs.

Option C seems like a good look that my dog would like.

Rawhide isn't good for a dog's digestive track, so I would choose the non-rawhide option.

I like the name of the product best.

I would buy the rawhide free option over any option that contains rawhide as it can have negative health and safety impacts on the dogs.

I would pick C because it seems like you get the most in the package. The other packages are smaller in size with not as many training sticks.

My rankings are arbitrary, as I would not buy ANY of the products shown. I buy tons of dog treats on Amazon, but they're all vegan, so none of the products shown here would EVER cross my mind to buy. If any of the choices had been vegan, it would've been my #1.

C for sure cause I buy these already on Amazon for my saint Bernard and he loves them! D and B would be my 2nd choice they sound good also for him. Then lastly A- I already use Greenies for dental sticks for him

I like that option C features raw hid free treats, these are way better on my dog’s gut health.

I picked this one because my dog currently loves this brand and bones. They have cute packaging that stands out more than the others also.

Option C because it was talking about using real chicken to wrap the treat. Plus there was an ample amount in the package

Option C was my first choice, because is not very good for dogs. So I try to stay away from it. The other options all seemed fairly similar, so they were just selected on no particular basis. At that point, for me it would mainly come down to price and amount that is in the package.

C I like the package and the image. DI like the package. There are too many chews in the image. A I like the package. B I don't like the package.

C is my favorite because it is real chicken and it is rawhide free. The final 3 are below it because they are all rawhide. A is second because it uses real chicken. D is above B because B says chik'n. Even though it says it has real chicken I always automatically think it is fake if the name isn't the actual word.

The only ones I would consider is option C. They are made with real chicken and rawhide free.

I ranked in order of package design aesthetic. I feel like the bottom two ranked or first two are more appealing to grab my attention. Followed by the green package. Last choice packaging is bland.

I wouldn't choose anything that has rawhide in it.

I would prefer rawhide free products

I chose C because it is rawhide free.

I'd prefer to buy the rawhide-free treats since rawhide is a choking hazard for many dogs.

I like the two choices, C and A, which specify the number of treats in a bag.

I love option C the most because they are the tastiest looking ones which I'm sure my dog would prefer the most.

I chose option C first as the name Dreambone just sounds much more appetizing and is easier to remember than the other three. It is similar to milk bone which is a standard name for dog treats. I also like the shape of these treats because they are twists. I liked option B second because of the twists and the other two were just not as interesting.

Option C!!! First choice. I don't know if anyone reads this, and I am sorry if this makes you upset...my dog, who passed away in December, the love of my life, he loved DreamBone. He never had these, but he loved other DreamBone twists. Option D is my second choice. Again, my beautiful Diego loved DreamBone, and I know this would have been his second favorite from the list. SO, I speak for him, and I bought for him, and I felt joy because of him. I picked Option A, because I know I would buy this for my current dog. Mostly, and this is embarrassing, because the dog in the picture looks like his best dog friend. My final choice, Option B, is not something I can see myself purchasing. The item looks too small for my dog, who is HUGE.

I think the packaging/design in C looks the most high quality to me

I like seeing a dog on the packaging.

I picked C first because it said how many were in a package. A was next because it said about it being high protein and good for dental. B was next because it appeared all nature, but didn't list specific claims. D didn't look as apealing and my dogs would chew through those in a second.

Frankly they all say rawhide except for c which is rawhide free. I don’t buy rawhide for my dog At all so only C would be chosen by me

The neon green color of the packaging for A looked unnatural. I liked that D showed me what the treats looked like outside of the packaging.

I think the dog on this one looks the cutest. I like how it is happy and smiling with it's tongue out. I also like the way the treats look and laid out in front of the package. My dog has had similar looking ones before and really likes them

I like D the most. I think the packaging and description stands out.

Can easily see the treat itself and judge it's quality

I like that I can see the treats in D and B. D provides me with the best view of the product, consequently it is my first choice. C seems interesting given they are twists but I am not sure my dog would prefer them over sticks. A looks very ordinary so it is my last choice.

The sample with the dog treats outside of the bag is appealing to me in D

The twists look packed with chicken. I feel like any dog would love these treats.

I prefer the dog on the packaging in option D, so that is the dog treat I would choose.

I like that I can clearly see the product

I prefer option D because to me it looks the most tasty and delicious. Option A and B look very intriguing as well. Option C looks the least scrumptious for my dog!

I like d. Getting a clear view of the great helps the decision making.

the dog seems happier.

Options D and A both is grain free as they claim, option A claims it supports dental health of dog so they are on top.

I chose option D. I like the shape of the sticks as I think it would keep my dog busy.

Among all the options, I select option D as my first choice because the images shows the outer packaging as well as inner products, that's why people can understand the products properly. Other options are also good, as there are many sticks to give the pet or dog for treats.

I want to see the dogs on the cover. They are cute, especially the ones in D and A, hence the high rankings

I like that the sticks look appetizing (for a dog) and that it also shows the real product

I choose option D as my first choice because the image shows the actual product along with the outer packaging. The people can understand the actual product and they can attract by the outer packaging of the product.

Options d and a with dogs on the package look more appealing and would entice me to purchase.

Based on the description, D is natural product and also grain free so I would buy D.

I think the jungle treats are the cutest here

Option D is my choice because I like the image of the product shown outside of the package which gives me a better idea for my pet.

I prefer the products that have an image of the dog treats separate from the packaging so you can see what they look like

I like that with D and B you seem to be able to really see the dog treats, and I like seeing what my pet will eat.

Options D,A and B have good packaging design and color scheme. Option D gives you a great look at the treat.

Personally I chose Option D first because I need a most effective, tasty and hygienic food for my dog, Here I can see the details are given very clearly in this option. Next I choose Option b for packaging is good and looking good as well. Last Option A and C is all most same as per packaging .

The color of the chicken looks more authentic and not dyed in choices D, B, and C. I like that choice D shows the product as the main appeal of the packaging and has a simple label. It comes off as more trustworthy.

this one shows the full product outside of the package making it easier for me to visualize.

I like choice D because I feel the bones look more inviting and look more natural for dogs

Option D and A were tied, they both have packaging that draws my attention with the dogs easily being seen and a picture of the product on the outside so you know what to expect. Option B just looked extremely bland.

D looks exciting to buy for a dog and high quality. A looks very normal and healthy for a dog treat label. C looks cheap. B looks cheap and plain without anything helpful.

I like that D and A show the contents outside of the package so that I can examine size, shape and quality. B has packaging that is colorful, bright, bold and eye catching. C is the least informative.

I ranked these in the order that I was able to get a good idea of what the product looked like/texture and also considered design and amount I'd receive

I chose d because I thought it would be the best for dogs

I prefer the look of the treats in my top choices.

I chose D first because I liked the packaging and the description listed it as chicken wrapped which to me sounded healthier than the description that said wrapped with real chicken in choice C. I didn't think the green packaging connected well for choice B and I chose A last as it kind of looked like generic store brand packaging.

I like the dog treats in this order, with D being my most likely pick because the packaging looks better than the others.

Option D just looks like a high-quality product that my dogs would enjoy, it actually kind of looks good.