I like the idea of a walk rather than cheezily discovering

Sounds nicer and more intriguing.

I chose A because a walk implies physically traveling through Italy.

I like the concept of walking through an area rather than being told I'm discovering it. Being told to "discover" something sounds like more of an advertisement than an invitation to enjoy.

I like option A. I think the phrase takes me there as I visualize myself walking.

I like a walk through, it is more casual.

Option A is better because it mentions walking which better describes a hiking scenario.

Discovering sounds like a general purpose tourism thing that can include car, boat, horse etc.

Using the word "walk" is more descriptive and I can feel what that scenario would be like.

This subtitle fits better with the overall title in theme and focus.

A think a walk through like in option A makes it seem more romantic and freeing than discovering. Option B makes it sound like discovering is a task.

I choose Option A because it makes much more sense than Option B. It is grammatically correct how Option A states the subtitle which makes it better than Option B.

The term "a walk" I'm option a sounds actionable and something you do. Be there term discovering which is just reading.

Your choice of words 'pilgrimage' suggests this is not just another travel book, but that word communicates a spiritual retreat. Thus, I chose A b/c the subtitle used the word 'walk.' A walk better communicates pilgrimage to me. The use of the word 'solitude' in the title also communicates that same message. Option B is more vanilla, more generic. It could be the subtitle of a general travel guide for that part of Italy.

I prefer using the word "walk" as it better indicates it is a hiking book.

I like the title better

I liked Option A better because the question says it is for a hiking/pilgrimage book. I would feel like the subtitle in Option B "discovering" would be more of a traveling guide (like Frommers or Lonely Planet) vs what the book is actually supposed to be about.

A walk through evokes more of a hiking feeling to me.

Sounds more active and engaging.

"Discovering" sounds a lot like every other book on the shelf. "Walk through" sounds different. It makes me think this will be different, something for the person that doesn't want to see the "hidden" tourist dumps, but fort he person who will put on a backpack and venture out to see the local areas.

"A Walk Through" meshes better with hiking/pilgrimage better than "Discovering" so that is why I chose Option A.

"A walk" tied in the subtitle quite well to the topic of the book, which is hiking.

Discovering sounds more exciting

I like this because it makes it sound more interesting.

I like that it says discovering because the book would seem more like we are finding it with the writer.

i like B and how it is "discovering hidden valley"

I like walking but not everyone else does. I think B would be a bit more generic for all ages/abilities/interests.

love discovering, especialy hidden places, better yet in italy

I prefer this option because it is not limited to walking or hiking. It might interest a larger demographic of people.

Discovering sounds far more enticing than simply walking.

B sounds more exciting and immersive.

I think this one works better with the title because of hidden going with solitude, Ii think it gives a better insight.

This title was more engaging and I was more drawn to this title.

It's a more simple title for a secondary one, the other to me is just less intriguing.

Option B because it say discover which, to me, implies finding/learning something new. That's what international travel is all about.

"Discovering" is more active and engaging than "A Walk Through." In other words, I like that B sounds more dynamic and action-oriented.

Discovering is a much better word for a pilgrimage book, it sounds inspiring.

"Discovering" is simpler and has more positive annotations. It gives more of an idea of action and adventure, which makes the book more interesting-sounding and attractive.

I think Italy is all about trying to discover different aspects of it

You can discover and understand yourself through this subtitle

This option sounds more interesting and inticing. Like you are finding an area not know to the common folk.

My choice is B because "Discovering" in the subtitle makes it feel adventurous and as I hike I will be discovering unique and unusual places in Italy. It makes me wonder what I might discover. It makes me want to read this book more than Option A. I like the original title "Sun, Storm and Solitude" a lot.

The word Discovering is strong here and makes me want to learn more and I would probably purchase this book.

I think it makes the place sound more exciting and exclusive like not many people have been there or found it.

You always want to find the the hidden stuff in a city and this title will show you that you can find them

I chose option B because I thought that the subtitle was more professional in terms of how subtitle was worded and it sounded more interesting when added to the main title of the book.

I would rather discover something than walk through it so option B is the one I would choose to read.

I think this sounds better when you say it out load compared to the other one,

The verb focus of option B makes it sound more interesting than the more passive, noun-focused option A.

Discovering Hidden Italy sounds more exciting than "A walk through hidden Italy"